I’ve been browsing a few teen writing sites, and by far
inkpop is my favorite. Here’s a comparison between
Wattpad (apparently the most popular) and inkpop:
UPLOADING
Wattpad has an upload-by-chapter feature for books as opposed to inkpop’s 10,000-words-first approach. Personally I like being able to upload the chapters separately and immediately better, but then again inkpop’s rule for books might make you want to write more. It just depends on the person, I guess.
COMMUNITY
They both have forums, but for me, I prefer inkpop’s. The Wattpad ‘Clubs’ might be confusing to people at first, and plus, the threads beside the promo threads tend to get drowned out. Not that there isn’t a lot of promotion going on in inkpop, but there’s more threads for socializing and such.
QUALITY
For the quality of the majority of the stories on the sites, I prefer inkpop. Wattpad’s “What’s Hot” list is somewhat of a joke sometimes; it’s well known for its multitude of cliches and similar plots (here are some well known ones: stories where a vampire falls for a human, stories about werewolf imprinting [don’t even get me started on that one], kidnappers and their hostages falling for each other, literal ‘boy-next-door’ stories, and so on.) The quality of the writing is, well… sometimes it’s pretty bad. I like Wattpad, though, because it’s fun to find the gems that just don’t get recognized, unfortunately.
Inkpop, however… let’s put it this way: if you don’t want competition and consider yourself a serious writer, go to Wattpad. Almost every story I’ve read on inkpop is amazing. A lot are publishing- worthy. Actually, someone from inkpop recently got published by HarperCollins (the ones who sponsor inkpop), I believe.
CRITIQUING
There are some serious critiquers on Wattpad, though you’ll likely recieve a line or two of standard, glowing praise. There are people like that on inkpop, too, but mostly people there know how to give good feedback. Maybe we just need to teach Wattpaders how to give helpful feedback. Hmm.
EASE OF NAVIGATION
I’m used to both sites but I hear from newbies that Wattpad’s a lot easier to navigate. Personally I find the orange disorienting, but most agree that Wattpad’s easier to navigate. I like Inkpop’s newsfeed, but at the same time I like the layout of Wattpad’s home page, disorienting or not.
RANKINGS
Inkpop uses picks for a ranking system. The more picks a book (or short story, poem, essay, you get the point) gets, the higher its ranking. If you pick books that are trending, your ranking will go up. You can see how that might get corrupted, though; in the past, it has been, but for the most part it’s a pretty nice way.
Wattpad uses votes, which are kind of like picks, only you can vote for anything at any time while inkpop limits you to five picks per twenty-four hours. Also, on Wattpad, the most popular on the homepage are ranked by genre, which I kind of like. The thing is, though, people have been known to put things as a different genre than what it is so it would have less competition. There’s good and bad in both systems.
So that’s my comparison. Personally I prefer inkpop (partially because I was on that first, and partially because I got annoyed with the text-talk grammar and cliche-ness of some Wattpad stories.) It’s a toss-up, though, depending on what you place the most emphasis on. Which would you prefer?
http://punkclassicartist.tumblr.com/